Home > Blog > Cash Out vs. HELOC vs. Home Equity Loan: Which Is the Best Option Right Now and Why?

Cash Out vs. HELOC vs. Home Equity Loan: Which Is the Best Option Right Now and Why?

It is a tough time for the property market, and the spike in mortgage rates can be one of the reasons people consider investment property. Through home equity-tapping, one can make outstanding enhancements and repairs to their house, consolidate their debts, or pay off expensive bills. However, making up one’s mind on whether to choose cash out refinance vs HELOC, or home equity loan can sometimes seem monotonous. For this reason, evaluating these alternatives to get rid of the trouble sources sufficiently matters. This paper concentrates on comparing these options based on the interest rate, repayment terms, and everyone’s costs. Consequently, this manner of making decisions will only add to your financial knowledge base such as refinance vs HELOC, enabling you to make choices that align with your objectives and specific circumstances.

Cash-Out Refinance

Which is better refinance or home equity loan? Cash-out refinancing involves replacing your old, smaller mortgage with a new, larger loan. The new loan amount, minus the remaining balance on your mortgage, is distributed to you in cash, providing access to your accumulated home equity. The home’s value is assessed, typically allowing for a new loan of up to 80–85% of the appraised value. Once your previous mortgage is settled, the remaining funds can be used for home improvements, debt consolidation, education expenses, or other essential needs.


  • Access to a substantial lump sum of cash
  • Potentially lower interest rate than other loan types
  • Fixed, predictable monthly payments
  • Possible tax deductions on mortgage interest


  • Closing costs can be significant (3–6% of the loan amount).
  • Increases your overall mortgage debt
  • Your home is at risk if you can’t make payments.
  • May you reset the term of your mortgage to 30 years?

It is important to remember that a cash out refinance vs home equity loan, although it will provide extra funds, will bear the long-term costs with interest. Restructuring the loan term can lead to the transfer of more interest payments, but the risk of foreclosure should not be underestimated if your financial state were to change.

HELOC: The Flexible Path

You can leverage equity without fully refinancing through a home equity vs refinance line of credit (HELOC). Think of it as a credit card with a credit line based on your home’s equity.

The lender determines your HCFI, setting the maximum percentage of your home’s appraised value you can borrow, usually up to 85%. Your credit scores dictate the line of credit amount. During the draw period, typically ten years, you can access funds as needed, paying only interest and deferring principal payments. Do you have to refinance to get a home equity loan? After the draw period ends and the repayment period begins, the entire amount, including interest, must be repaid within 20 years.


  • Revolving credit for financial flexibility as needs arise
  • Interest is only paid on funds borrowed.
  • Potentially tax-deductible interest
  • There are no closing costs in most cases.


  • Variable interest rates can cause payments to fluctuate.
  • Outstanding balances accrue interest during the draw period.
  • Borrowing power decreases as you pay down the principal
  • Home is collateral; missed payments could lead to foreclosure.

A refinance vs HELOC gives you convenient access to money for home improvement, investing, or generally using the funds to resolve other outstanding debts. By contrast, variable-rate bonds are particularly risky and should be cautiously accepted. This should be done carefully so we stay calm by writing a significant policy and more over-interest, which can build up over time.

Home equity loan

A home equity loan is one of the options people frequently turn to for the immediate bulk sum from their lender. Through the tool of borrowing that works against your home equity loan vs cash out refinance, you are given the opportunity with a fixed interest rate and payment plan.

Similarly, in the case of the cash-out refinance, the worth of your house (appraised value) determines the margin of your credit. If your existing mortgage balance represents 85% of your house’s value, you can borrow up to the amount exceeding this percentage. The lender meets your immediate need by giving you a one-time lump sum loan, which you have to pay back with an interest rate set up at a fixed rate in an agreed period of five to thirty years.


  • Receive funds as a lump-sum cashout.
  • Fixed interest rates mean unchanging monthly payments.
  • Interest may be tax-deductible.
  • Loan terms are finite, unlike a HELOC’s draw period.


  • Equity depletes as you borrow against your home’s value.
  • Closing costs can be pricey upfront.
  • Missed payments put your home ownership at risk.
  • Less flexible repayment than a HELOC’s revolving structure

The best option for a second mortgage would be a home equity loan if you know exactly what this money should be used for and for how much money. The time frame for the repayment is in line with a traditional mortgage, which is an excellent help for budgeting. You must check expenses and observe the likely consequences on equity, which classify you as a homeowner.

Choosing the Right Home Equity Option

Refinancing your mortgage, home equity line of credit, and home equity loan vs cash out refinance loans each serve to size up your house. However, considering which one is better can be challenging. To help simplify your comparison, here’s a quick overview of the critical attributes of each option:

FeatureCash-Out RefinanceHELOCHome Equity Loan
Access to FundsLump sumRevolving line of creditLump sum
Interest RatesPotentially lower fixed ratesVariable ratesFixed rates
Repayment TermsNew 30-year mortgage term10-year draw period, then repayment periodFixed repayment period
Closing CostsHigher upfront costsUsually minimalModerate upfront costs
Tax DeductionsMortgage interest may be deductibleInterest may be deductibleInterest may be deductible

The right choice depends on your current financial needs, risk tolerance, and repayment timeline. Cash out refinance vs HELOC may offer larger funds at potentially better rates but involves higher initial costs. HELOCs offer immediate financial control but come with variable interest rates. Home equity loans provide a lump sum with a fixed interest rate.

If none of these options align with your goals after considering their pros and cons, consulting a financial advisor is advisable. They can tailor a suitable strategy for you and the long term.

Subscribe to Our Newsletters and Get Your Free Guide to Smart Property Buying

    Stay informed, make informed decisions, and discover the secrets to successful real estate investments.

    Connect with us

    Whether you’re buying a home or are ready to refinance, our professionals can help